25% off Which? Gardening
Pay £36.75 for the first year and get the garden you want for less
Get this offerBy clicking a retailer link you consent to third party cookies that track your onward journey. If you make a purchase, Which? will receive an affiliate commission which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.
Slugs and snails are very discerning in what they eat, bypassing the weeds to devour our favourite plants.
They're difficult to stop and, while you can still use bated pellets containing ferric phosphate, biological control containing nematodes or just pick off any slugs or snails you see, different types of physical barriers are an increasingly popular choice.
The Which? Gardening experts looked at the current options to find out which are the most effective.
The damp winter and spring weather in 2024 is providing just the conditions that slugs and snails enjoy so be ready to protect your plants.
Breathe new life into your outside spaces. Sign up for our Gardening newsletter, it's free monthly
Only logged-in Which? members can view the full test results. Join Which? now to get instant access to our test scores and Best Buy recommendations below.
Slug and snail controls | Overall score | Type of barrier control | Ease of use | Time taken before first damage seen | Time taken for >10% of leaves to be eaten | Percentage of leaves damaged at the end of the trial | Number of plants damaged | Durability of treatment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Doff Slugs Be Gone Defence Gel | ||||||||
Ecofective Slug Defence Plant Spray | ||||||||
Ecofective Slug Defence Barrier Granules | ||||||||
Evergreen Slug Clear Slug & Snail Barrier | ||||||||
Grazers G2 Slugs & Snails | ||||||||
PlantGrow Slug & Snail natural barrier | ||||||||
SlugLess Pet Safe, Spiky Slug & Snail Deterent |
Best Buys need to score more than 75%.
SCORE: Ignores price and is based on: time before first damage seen 20%; time taken for >10% of leaves to be eaten; percentage of leaves eaten at the end of the trial 20%; number of plants damaged at the end of the trial 20%; ease of application 10%; durability of treatment 10%. All scores are based on comparisons between treated and untreated plants in the same three plots. Scores for the untreated plot used as a control are given separately.
Pay £36.75 for the first year and get the garden you want for less
Get this offerGet more advice on getting rid of slugs and snails
With the slime trails they produce, molluscs are well adapted to travelling over the most inhospitable surfaces to get to feed, which is why things like eggshells rarely work. So we're glad to find some barrier controls that reduced the amount of damage as successfully as the baited pellets. The crucial factor seems to be finding something molluscs dislike enough that they'll feed on unprotected plants instead of crossing it.
It's quite likely that you'll still see some damage to your vulnerable plants, especially when wet weather brings a lot of hungry molluscs out of the prowl.
But if you can deter slugs and snails long enough to let plants establish and grow, your plants have a much better chance of survival.
We've tested slug and snail controls regularly over the years and found that many common suggestions are very ineffective.
The trial was carried out in a well-ventilated polytunnel in soil free from slugs and snails. Three 1m2 plots, each surrounded by slug and snail-proof fence, were used for each product.
The plots were planted with six young lettuce plants and six young sunflower plants.
The products were applied to three lettuce and three sunflower plants in each plot, while the other six plants were left untreated. A further three plots were set up with had no treatments.
All treatments were reapplied as needed during the trial, following product instructions.
We placed 10 slugs and five snails in each plot. Plots were watered heavily near the start of the trial to see what effect heavy rain has on the products and were watered regularly after that to keep soil moist.
The trial ran for three weeks. We assessed how easy it was to use the products, how well they lasted, and we regularly recorded leaf damage and the number of plants damaged on each plot.